ICT Banner

 

Welcome to the latest issue of the ICT Journal.

This Journal is distributed quarterly to our PCB Industry contacts. You may add your name to the distribution list by selecting the option below. There is no cost or future commitment.

ict logo

The Journal of
The  Institute of Circuit Technology
Vol 19 No 1
January 2026

Links to Contents

  Author  Section
Editor's Introduction Richard Wood-Roe  1
Calendar of Events Emma Hudson 2
Foundation Course Emma Hudson 3
Capabilities and Challenges in Taking the Step from HDI to Advanced HDI Roger Massey et al MKS Atotech, Berlin 4 
Study of Hole Wall Dielectric Crack Defects in Power Module Heavy Copper Printed Circuit Boards Sun Fu et al
 Zhuhai Founder PCB Development Limited
5
The AI Boom is Driving Technological Change at Every Level - Beware Alun Morgan 

6

ICT Symposium Review: Sustainability and the Circular Economy  Pete Starkey 7
Leading-Edge Developments in Electronics Manufacturing. Institute of Circuit Technology Winter Seminar Review. Pete Starkey  8 

Members News:

Richard Wood-Roe  9
Industry News:   Richard Wood-Roe 10
Corporate Members

11

Council Members 12
Editor's Notes Richard Wood-Roe 13

 

Section 1 - Editor's Introduction

rick profile2

Welcome to the winter edition of our Journal. Please forward this Journal to any of your colleagues who may be interested. They can then subscribe using the link above to receive regular copies.
There are 2 papers, Capabilities and Challenges in Taking the Step from HDI to Advanced HDI and Study of Hole Wall Dielectric Crack Defects in Power Module Heavy Copper Printed Circuit Boards.
We have reviews of our Annual Symposium and Christmas Technical Seminar and an article from Alun Morgan - The AI Boom is Driving Technological Change at Every Level - Beware. There are also Members and Industry news sections. 
I hope you find the contents interesting.

Go back to Contents

   

Section 2
Calendar of Events

emma hudson Emma Hudson
Technical Director and Membership Secretary

Dates

Details 

3-4th Feb 2026 EIPC Winter Conference - Aix-en-Provence
3-5th Feb 2026 Southern Manufacturing Show - Farnborough
14-19th Mar 2026 IPC Apex - Anaheim 
23-26th March 2026 ICT Foundation Course - Chester University
14th April 2026 ICT Evening Seminar
9-10th Jun 2026 EIPC Summer Conference 
23rd Sept 2026 ICT Annual Symposium
29 - 30th Sept 2026 Microelectronics UK - Excel, London
10-13th Nov 2026 Electronica - Munich 
24th Nov 2026 ICT Christmas Evening Seminar
  Go back to Contents

 

 Section 3 - ICT 2026 Foundation Course 23rd - 26th March 2026

Please see below the full details of this years' Foundation Course in PCB Design and Manufacture. This annual course is proving very popular for PCB Manufacturing Engineers, Quality Engineers, Managers and Designers. It is an ideal course for anyone wishing to pursue their personal development and advance their knowledge of PCB manufacturing.  There is also a booking form below for your convenience.

 Foundation Course
Foundation Course Booking Form
Go back to Contents

  

Section 4

Capabilities and Challenges in Taking the Step from HDI to Advanced HDI
Roger Massey, Lars-Eric Pribyl
Christopher Seidemann, Thomas Thomas
MKS Atotech, Berlin

Abstract
Across most, if not all electronics applications, there has been a continual drive to increase complexity while reducing size, weight and power consumption. In order to achieve this, there has been significant pressure on the PCB industry to minimize feature sizes wherever possible, while maintaining high volume and cost effective processes. Rising to this challenge, there has been significant efforts made over recent years to adapt techniques common to the IC packaging sector and apply them into “traditional” High Density Interconnect (HDI) PCB manufacture, thus moving from HDI to “advanced HDI”

While there is little, if any, need for the full Semi Additive Process (SAP) to be applied in many applications, there have been two sub divisions of SAP developed which are relevant when looking to move into advanced HDI PCB manufacture. The modified SAP (mSAP) and advanced modified SAP (amSAP) approaches are combinations of the subtractive HDI and additive SAP techniques which readily open up the technology window and allow a decrease in feature size while still remaining similar to the existing HDI approach.

This paper compares all four of the techniques and identifies the technology level available through each before focusing on those most relevant to advanced HDI manufacture where we then discuss some of the challenges they present as well as offering potential solutions.

Background
Historically, there has been a clear separation between the technical capabilities of the “PCB” and the “wafer” sectors, with PCBs typically supporting features in the 10s of microns scale, while the IC industry supports those on the nanometer scale. With the advent of ball grid array-based packages in the 1980s, and the adoption of an organic “IC Substrate”, that separation began to reduce, and while the packaging industry is certainly catching up, the separation does continue, albeit somewhat smaller than in the past. The Semi Additive Process (SAP) that was developed in order to facilitate package substates, has enabled organic based PCBs to achieve features approximately 10 μm in size, with features smaller than 5 μm now becoming commonplace on the packaging industry roadmaps. As would be expected, this capability comes at a cost, and the adoption of SAP has remained predominantly within packaging applications, where that cost can be justified as well as accommodated.

Meanwhile, innovation within “traditional PCBs” has been driven largely by mobile devices as they pursue their own nirvana of smaller, lighter and more capable devices. Again, the “boom time” of the 1980s saw the development of HDI with a shift away from multiple rigid cores undergoing a single lamination cycle followed by mechanically drilled through holes, into multiple sequential lamination cycles and laser drilled blind micro vias (BMV). Based on a subtractive approach, modern HDI processes readily create features approximately 40 μm in size, and with care, this can be reduced, but as with wafer and package substrates, a capability gap soon formed between HDI and the more challenging package substrates.

While SAP can easily bridge that gap, the associated costs rarely support this, and so innovation again took a step forward and “modified” SAP (mSAP) was developed. Taking features from both SAP and HDI production, mSAP supports features in the region of 25-40 μm and the newer “advanced modified” SAP (amSAP) is anticipated to push this further to 20 μm or lower.

While the situation may appear quite simple, nomenclature varies depending on the user as well as their location. For example, in Asia, HDI, subtractive, mSAP and SAP are all common terms, while in Europe and the USA, you’re still going to hear about SAP and HDI/subtractive, but mSAP is often referred to as Advanced or Ultra HDI. Interestingly, the industry as a whole does seem to recognize amSAP, but it’s not a widely used term and is often grouped into mSAP or advanced/ultra HDI. As such, clarification is always best during discussions, and while SAP can be considered as being the ultimate solution to improved capability, the mSAP approach is often the more suitable, and certainly more cost-effective route.

The Road to mSAP and Advanced HDI
As outlined previously and shown schematically in Figure 1, the SAP and HDI techniques can be considered as being the upper and lower ends of the capability window for PCB manufacturing techniques involving microvias. In their simplest forms, there are two significant differences in their approach. Firstly, SAP starts with a bare dielectric surface while HDI utilizes a copper clad laminate, and secondly, following via formation and primary metallization, HDI adopts a flash and panel plate approach while SAP follows a full pattern plate route. The critical impact of these is that when the PCB is ready to etch the final circuitry, the thickness of the surface Copper is significantly lower for SAP (less than 1 μm) compared to HDI (typically greater than 15 μm), and it is this which ultimately supports the ability to create finer features. This previous statement is obviously a heavy oversimplification but the “key take aways” are:

• There is a strong relationship between surface copper thickness and etched line and space capability.
• Thinner surface Copper facilitates finer lines and spaces.


fig 1Figure 1. Comparison of SAP, amSAP, mSAP and Subtractive HDI Process Capability

While a full pattern plate approach using SAP will certainly support the production of features between 20 and 40 μm in size, it is not cost effective to do so. Conversely, the subtractive HDI technique is more cost efficient, but is not able to support the same feature size. As such, it would be reasonable to assume that a combination of the two techniques would potentially be both cost effective and technically capable, and this was the basis on which mSAP and later, amSAP were developed.

As stated above, the thickness of the surface Copper is critical in determining the minimum feature size that can be formed, and even when using ¼ oz. (9 μm) Copper foils, the panel plate approach of HDI is limited to features greater than 40 μm. However, the use of panel plating makes for a very robust process, and while a full pattern plate process is technically more capable, it also does require more engineering control and overall care during operation.

The mSAP technique builds on the strengths of both the HDI and SAP process operations by combining a thin flash panel plate (HDI) with a subsequent pattern plate step (SAP). By doing this, the total surface Copper thickness can be reduced to less than 10 μm, which is more than sufficient to enable the features finer than those achievable with existing HDI techniques. With amSAP, the surface Copper thickness is further reduced to under 5 μm by omitting the flash plate step all together and relying on only the primary metallization layer to support a full pattern plate approach, by doing this the achievable feature size can be further reduced as shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Comparison of SAP, amSAP, mSAP and Subtractive HDI Process and Capability

table 1
Clearly, mSAP and amSAP can be considered as being intermediate steps but they offer a number of key benefits when transitioning from HDI to mSAP and not SAP:

• Lower investment cost – There is the potential to use existing HDI equipment platforms.
• Robust process – Flash plating after primary metallization provides significant protection to the electroless Copper
layer which has benefits for manufacturing.
• Product reliability – Direct flash plate after electroless Copper is considered as being the best opportunity to provide
high reliability BMVs.


Challenges And Changes Needed When Transitioning to mSAP and Advanced HDI

fig 2
Figure 2. Process Flow Schematics for HDI (A), mSAP (B) and amSAP (C)

Figure 2 outlines the key steps in typical HDI, mSAP and amSAP, and as can be seen, the general operations are very similar. The BMV needs to be formed and metallized, traces need to imaged, plated and etched, and finally the traces themselves need to be prepared for dielectric lamination. In view of this, it would be reasonable to assume that many of the existing HDI processes can be used for mSAP and amSAP; however, this is not necessarily the case.

BMV formation – Prior to laser direct drilling (LDD), it is typical to apply some form of pretreatment in order to maximize laser absorption in the Copper foil and optimize drill performance. In HDI production, this pretreatment is often performed with a modified oxide alternative process which is usually etched based. Similarly, after via formation, there is usually a surface Copper splash (Figure 3B) which needs to be removed prior to metallization, and again, typically an etch based treatment is used.

 fig 3Figure 3. Copper Surface Before (A) and After (B) BMV Formation and After LLD Post Treatment (C)

With an HDI build, the Copper foil on the laminate material is of sufficient thickness to accommodate the required total etch depth, typically 2-3 μm for pre-treatment and 1-2 μm for post-treatment, and still leave sufficient Copper on the surface to allow subsequent processing. However, in an mSAP approach, the surface Copper thickness is comparable to the standard etch depth used in HDI production, and for amSAP it is substantially lower than the etch depth, and in both cases, there is high likelihood that all the surface Copper will be removed after LDD post treatment. Modified processes have been developed, where the total etch depth associated with the LDD pre and post treatment have been significantly reduced (1-3 μm in total) to ensure that not only is laser absorption still enhanced, but perhaps more critically, the surface Copper is not entirely removed after treatment.


Primary Metallisation – Electroless Copper remains the process of choice for both mSAP and amSAP based manufacturing, and as mSAP continues to make use of a flash plate step it may be possible to use existing equipment. However, there are two equipment-related factors that should be considered:


• Copper thickness distribution – One of the key factors within mSAP and amSAP is the reduction in surface Copper thickness, as this ultimately impacts the final etch capability. As Copper thickness decreases, thickness variation becomes of increasing importance, so when considering a move to mSAP, the plating distribution should be minimized
• In line flash plating – There have been many discussions in recent years on the subject of stacked BMV reliability, and a frequent conclusion from these is that any contamination occurring between the plated layers is detrimental to BMV reliability [1,2,3]. Subsequently, there is a strong recommendation to minimize delays and the risk of oxidation between primary and secondary metallization, with the ideal situation being that the panels exit the final rinse from the electroless line and go immediately into the first step of the flash plate process.


While both of the above points may be accommodated in traditional vertical basket lines, it is much more readily achieved and controlled in conveyorized horizontal equipment, and this is now considered as being the process of record for high volume mSAP production.

As the line/space requirement decreases, the Copper to be removed during the final etch step also decreases, and while there has always been a tendency to “over etch” in order to accommodate dielectric roughness and any plated Copper thickness variations, with tracks <30 μm in width there is an increased occurrence of line width reduction as well as undercut. Hence, the degree of “over etch” when using mSAP and amSAP is minimized, which also increases the risk of other etch related defects. Palladium residues arising from excessive precipitation in the electroless Copper activation step, or incomplete rinsing after the activation, will act as etch masks, and these in combination with a reduced “over etch” further increases the risk of etch defects and short circuits as shown in Figure 4.

fig 4Figure 4. Etch Short Associated with Palladium Residues

In order to combat this, specific activation processes have been developed for mSAP and amSAP production, where the pH of the predip and activators are more balanced so as to minimize unwanted Palladium precipitation and so reduce the occurrence of Palladium particles that are free to deposit on the board and inhibit the etch step.

As highlighted previously, the thickness of the surface Copper has a direct impact on the feature size. With the electroless Copper thickness typically being less than 1um, when using 3-4 μm Copper foils, the electroless thickness can easily become 20-25% of the total Copper thickness, and so is a factor that must be taken into account. Variations within the electroless Copper layer must be minimized as they can lead to etch distribution issues and ultimately Copper residues. The process equipment has a part to play in improving this, and while “over etching” can also resolve some variation, it can lead to other issues as discussed previously. In view of this, it is essential that the electroless Copper processes most suitable for mSAP and especially for amSAP would offer tangible improvements in their deposit thickness distribution. The latest generation of electroless Copper baths have been optimized to reduce thickness variation as much as possible, and when used in dedicated, horizontal process equipment, can yield dense copper layers with a very low thickness variation. of less than 10% compared to the more typical 20-30% for a standard HDI process.(Figure 5)

fig 5

Figure 5. Copper Thickness Distribution from Standard HDI and amSAP Electroless Copper Baths

While it is clear that electroless copper has to become thinner and more uniform in order to improve etch capability, this must not be achieved at the cost of other critical parameters. With microvias being the typical layer interconnects in mSAP applications, it is essential that the reliability of these joints is not compromised, and simply reducing the deposited surface Copper thickness risks this. With older generation processes, the throwing power (TP) of the electroless Copper bath is typically in the region of 30-40%, which means that in order to ensure good coverage at the base of the BMV, the surface Copper is at least twice as thick as that at the BMV target pad, and any reductions in surface Copper thickness will clearly lead to coverage issues at the base of the BMV. Modern electroless processes (Figure 6) offer throwing power in excess of 75%, which not only allows for reduced surface thickness in mSAP without any coverage issues, but also means that for amSAP, where Copper thickness in the BMV has to be maximized (there is no protective flash-plated layer); it can be accommodated without excessive thickness at the panel surface.

fig 6Figure 6. High Throwing Power Electroless Copper Baths

 

Table 2 Comparison of Throwing Power for HDI and mSAP/amSAP Electroless Copper Processes BMV Size x Height (μm)
table 2

Reliability is the other “hot topic” for all applications involving stacked BMVs [4,5] and here the newer electroless baths again offer significant benefits for all HDI, mSAP and amSAP applications. Publications examining joint reliability over the last 5-10 years have highlighted the importance of plated vias that are free of micro and even nano defects [6,7]. The way that the plated layers crystallize has been shown to be a vital factor in product performance, where defects and aligned grain boundaries in the microstructures act as cleavage plans and crack propagation sites. Figure 7A shows an epitaxial crystal structure where there are no significant defects visible, while Figure 7B shows one with a significant grain boundary alignment, which subsequently acted as a crack path during IR Reflow testing.

fig 7Figure 7. Good (A) and Poor (B) Plated BMV Microstructures

The many billions of BMVs that have been produced with “legacy plating baths” confirm that these older processes are still capable of forming reliable joints, but the new generations of plating baths have been developed with preferred microstructure in mind with the aim of achieving optimized reliability performance. 

Line Etching – With HDI boards, the larger feature size is sufficient to allow for a significant degree of over etch (2-3 μm) without any appreciable impact on track geometry. However, as feature size decreases, such over etch is not acceptable as this equates to approximately 10-20% track width reduction. Further as the solution delivery at the top of the track is more efficient than at the base of the track, there is an etch speed differential across the track height, which leads to the characteristic “trapezoidal” shape. (Figure 8)

fig 8Figure 8. Track Width Reduction and Poor Track Profile in mSAP with an HDI Etch

Next generation etch processes have been developed based on SAP applications where additives stabilize the etch rate across the track height and slow the speed at the top of the track as to be more comparable to that at the base. This not only leads to a more vertical etch profile (Figure 9B), but additives also reduce the etch differential between the plated Copper layers and reduce the occurrence of undercut (Figure 9A) that leads to poor track adhesion and ultimately lifting or missing traces.

fig 9Figure 9. Heavy Undercut (A) of the Electroless Copper can be Overcome by New Etch Processes (B)


Adhesion Promotion – As with traditional HDI processing, all the Copper tracks need to be treated with an adhesion promoter prior to lamination of the next dielectric layer. Historically this was achieved by growing a black Copper oxide on the panel surface, but this was superseded by the more robust oxide alternative (OA) processes during the late 1990s and the situation remains in much the same situation today. However, as the OA processes require some significant etching to take place, typically greater than 1 μm, this can again lead to significant line loss on smaller plated tracks. As such, the desire to maintain smaller feature sizes in combination with an increasing need for lower roughness in order to maximize signal integrity has led to the development of a series of low and even no etch adhesion promoters. (Figure 10)

fig 10
Figure 10. Inner Layer Adhesion Promoters Have Been Developed with Decreasing Etch Depth and Final Roughness

Through modification of the original processes, the organo-metallic layer typical to the OA process can be created without appreciable Copper removal and etch depths of approximately 0.5 μm are readily achievable. If an additional post process is adopted to apply a controlled organic adhesion coating, then the etch depth can be further decreased to less than 0.2 μm, and if only an organic adhesion system is used, then Copper removal becomes wholly unnecessary, beyond the need to ensure that all oxides and contaminants have been removed. These low etch adhesion promoters are now gaining traction and being qualified within the industry, especially in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and high-speed computing applications where signal loss is paramount. Meanwhile, the IC packaging producers are exploring the “more radical” non-etching adhesion systems, where adhesion is achieved solely through the application of chemical coatings that support bonding between the Copper traces and the overlying dielectric. While these processes are still under evaluation by substrate manufacturers it is anticipated that once they have become more widely adopted, they will, in time, “trickle down” into HDI and mSAP applications.


Summary
Latest generation mobile devices have adopted innovative advanced die packages, and this has led to PCB designs beyond the capabilities of the traditional subtractive HDI technique. In order to meet these new design criteria, many HDI manufacturers are turning to mSAP and/or amSAP in order to achieve the desired finer line and spaces. While some of the existing HDI infrastructure may be adaptable for mSAP and amSAP manufacture, specific processes have been developed to leverage the benefits of the newer manufacturing techniques that cannot otherwise be guaranteed if using existing HDI variations. 

Such new processes are present throughout the mSAP manufacturing cycle and cover all aspects from pre-treatment to enhance BMV formation, electroless and electrolytic copper deposition to provide improved coverage, via fill and reliability performance and surface treatments that maximize not only adhesion to a wide range of dielectrics, but do so with improved signal integrity properties. 

mSAP and amSAP have now become key technologies in today’s PCB industry as they offer significant jumps in process capability without the high investment costs associated with adopting a full SAP approach. Experience in Asia has shown that transitioning from subtractive HDI is readily achievable, although it does require some investment as well as a number of new yet enabling processes.


References
[1] Bernhard T, Massey R, Klaeden K, Zarwell S, Steinhaeuser E, Kempa S, Bruening F. Impact of Additives on the Recrystallisation of Plated Layers. Proceedings of International Microsystems, Packaging Assembly and Circuits Technology Conference 2022.
[2] Bernhard T, Dieter S, Massey R, Kempa S, Steinhäuser E, Brüning F. Cu Recrystallization and the Formation of Epitaxial and Non-Epitaxial Cu/Cu/Cu Interfaces in Stacked Blind Micro Via Structures. Proceedings of Electronic Components and Technology Conference 2021
[3] Bernhard T, Steinhäuser E, Kempa S, Krilles G, Massey R, Brüning F. Nickel Effect on Hydrogen Entrapment and Nanoporosity for Electroless Deposited Cu-Films. Proceedings of Electronic Components and Technology Conference 2020
[4] Magera J. et al. IPC-WP-023 “IPC Technology Solutions White Paper on Performance-Based Printed Board OEM Acceptance. Via Chain Continuity Reflow Test: The Hidden Reliability Threat — Weak Microvia Interface. May 2018
[5] Magera J. Strickland J.R “Copper Filled Microvias – The New Hidden Threat“. Proceedings of IPC Apex EXPO 2019
[6] Bernhard T, Branagan S, Schulz R, Bruning F, Stamp L, Wurdinger K, Kempa S. The Formation of Nanovoids in Electroless Cu Layers. MRS Advances 2019
[7] Bernhard T, Steinhäuser E, Kempa S, Krilles G, Klaeden K,Zarwell S, Bruning F, Massey R, Yu P. Copper Recrystallisation and Nanovoid Classification in Blind Micro Vias. Proceedings of International Microsystems, Packaging Assembly and Circuits Technology Conference 2021.

Editors Note: This paper was originally presented at IPC APEX EXPO 2025

Go back to Contents

   

Section 5

Study of Hole Wall Dielectric Crack Defects in Power Module Heavy Copper
Printed Circuit Boards

Sun Fu, Mike Feng, Jed Wong
Zhuhai Founder PCB Development Limited
Zhuhai, Guangdong, China

Abstract
Dielectric cracking along hole walls represents a significant reliability concern in heavy copper power module PCBs, frequently resulting in Hi-pot test failures. Hi-pot (High Potential) testing is also called a dielectric withstand voltage test. - It applies a voltage much higher than the normal operating voltage across points that should be electrically isolated.
Two distinct failure modes have been identified: (1) Z-direction dielectric cracks, associated with inner-layer non-functional pad design and drill bit cutting forces; and (2) horizontal dielectric cracks or pad delamination, primarily linked to stepped drilling processes.

Extensive experimental investigations demonstrate that reliability can be enhanced through targeted interventions: optimizing inner-layer pad design and managing drill bit service life to mitigate Z-direction cracking, and refining stepped drilling techniques to reduce pad delamination. These measures collectively improve hole wall integrity and significantly lower the reliability risks inherent in heavy copper PCB manufacturing.

 

Introduction

Power module PCBs are used in high-performance applications that require efficient power conversion, high current handling, and robust thermal management — including electric vehicles, renewable energy systems and industrial automation.

Modern energy products are increasingly characterized by high current, high voltage, significant heat dissipation, and thinner structural layers. These requirements demand continuous improvements in power module printed circuit boards (PCBs), particularly in current-carrying capacity, voltage resistance, and thermal performance. Meeting these challenges necessitates increasing PCB copper thickness [1] (Figure 1, Figure 2), while simultaneously developing thinner dielectric materials to support compact product designs [2].

For high layer-count, thin-dielectric, thick-copper power module PCBs, the interlayer dielectric and pattern-to-pattern dielectric are continuously subjected to elevated voltages, ranging from 400 V to 1500 V. This operating condition imposes stringent requirements on the raw materials, demanding enhanced voltage resistance and thermal stability. Inadequate voltage resistance represents a failure mode unique to power module PCBs.

Non-uniform copper thickness can result in tip discharges or partial discharges, while variations in dielectric thickness may reduce the minimum safe insulation distance. Together, these irregularities create the weakest breakdown channels, ultimately leading to high-voltage failure defects [3]. Consequently, the fabrication of thick-copper power module PCBs must prioritize the elimination of such breakdown pathways. Among the critical process steps, drilling has been identified as a major contributor to poor voltage resistance performance and requires careful optimization.

 

Fig 1 and 2

Dielectric Cracking and Voltage-Resistant Failure Induced by Drilling

Voltage-resistant failure in power module PCBs is closely associated with dielectric cracking in the hole wall, primarily induced during the drilling process. Two distinct crack orientations have been identified:

  • Z-direction cracks occur within the dielectric layer along the drilling axis, meaning the mechanical force responsible for the damage is applied vertically. These cracks are oriented perpendicular to the drilling direction and compromise the insulation integrity between layers (Figure 3).
  • Horizontal cracks develop around the non-functional pads of the hole wall and are often accompanied by severe annular ring separation. This failure mode is indicative of mechanical stress during stepped drilling or poor pad adhesion (Figure 4).

Both crack types contribute to the formation of weak dielectric pathways, increasing the risk of high-voltage breakdown and insulation failure.

Fig 3 Fig 4

 

Analysis of the causes of hole wall dielectric crack
The production process flow of thick copper power module printed circuit board is as follows:
Material release → Inner image transferring → Inner AOI → Punching → Brown oxide → Lamination → X-ray drilling target hole → Mechanical drilling → Deburring → Secondary drilling (slot holes) → Baking → Plasma cleaning → Desmear & PTH → Copper plating → ...Post process stations

Detection of Hole Wall Cracks
Hole wall cracks can be identified during cross-sectional inspection following copper plating. These defects are observed exclusively in thick-copper boards fabricated with halogen-free FR4 epoxy. Based on this occurrence, the primary process stations suspected of contributing to crack formation are lamination and drilling.

Z-Directional Dielectric Cracks
Z-directional dielectric cracks were predominantly observed in large-diameter holes ranging from 1.0 to 1.5 mm. These cracks were located within copper-free regions spanning several consecutive layers of the hole wall. Microscopic examination revealed copper plating infiltration along the crack edges (Figure 5), indicating that the defects originated during the drilling process.

Fig 5Further take the finished defective board (16-layers, inner layer 4OZ copper foil) on the same area of the three 1.30 mm PTH holes to do the cross-section analysis, and found that the middle one among the three-holes had cracks defect, but other two holes are not abnormal. By comparison these three holes, the inner layer of 2 holes on both sides is the full-copper design, while the hole in the middle of the three-holes is designed with nonfunctional pads on some inner layers and some inner layers are without nonfunctional pads (Figures 6-8). It is deduced that when the inner layer of the large hole is designed without a localized pad, the hole wall is subjected to a large impact force when drilling, which result in cracks in the copperfree zone of the dielectric.

Cross-Sectional Analysis of Defective Boards
A cross-sectional analysis was performed on a defective 16-layer board with inner layers composed of 4 oz copper foil. Examination focused on three adjacent plated through-holes (PTHs) with diameters of 1.30 mm. Among these, the central hole exhibited dielectric cracking, while the two flanking holes showed no abnormalities.

Comparative analysis revealed that the two intact holes were designed with continuous full-copper inner layers, whereas the defective central hole incorporated nonfunctional pads on certain inner layers, with other layers lacking pads entirely (Figures 6–8). This structural difference suggests that the absence of localized pads in large-hole designs subjects the hole wall to greater mechanical stress during drilling. The resulting impact force promotes crack formation within the copper-free dielectric zones, thereby compromising insulation integrity.

Fig 7 Fig 6 Fig 8

 

Horizontal Directional Dielectric Cracks

Process cross-section records revealed that horizontal directional cracks—defined as cracks formed under forces acting laterally along the hole wall—were exclusively observed in 16-layer thick-copper boards. No such defects were detected in boards with 10 to 14 layers. Examination of multiple 16-layer boards exhibiting crack defects highlighted several consistent characteristics:

  1. Hole diameter dependence: Cracks occurred only in small-diameter holes (<1.0 mm), most frequently within the 0.40–0.60 mm range.
  2. Localized occurrence: Horizontal cracks, manifested as pad pull-away, were concentrated on layers L4–L6 and L10–L11, with L5 showing the most severe damage (Figure 9).
  3. Drilling stress correlation: Quantitative analysis of drilling nail head dimensions (Figure 9) showed that the nail head at the L5 crack site reached 1.65 times its nominal size, whereas adjacent layers (L3 and L7) measured only 1.06–1.16 times. Based on production experience with 4 oz thick copper boards, nail head expansion typically does not exceed 1.5 times. The abnormal enlargement observed at L5 indicates that the copper pads in this layer were subjected to exceptional mechanical stress during drilling, leading to annular ring separation and subsequent crack formation.

fig9

Figure 9. Horizontal directional crack cross-section observation in 16-Layers thick copper board

 

Hole Wall Dielectric Crack Risk Factor Identification

Based on the cross-sectional analysis, the occurrence of hole wall dielectric cracks was preliminarily attributed to the drilling and lamination processes. To systematically identify the contributing factors, a 4M1E (Man, Machine, Material, Method, Environment) risk factor checklist was developed (Table 1). This framework facilitated a structured evaluation of potential influences across each category, enabling targeted mitigation strategies.

Table 1

The risk points in Table 1 were examined one by one with the following results:

1. Operator Competence

All four operators responsible for thick copper boards have more than one year of machine operation experience and hold valid certification. This minimizes the risk of incorrect parameter selection or improper drill bit usage.

2. Machine Capability

Drilling accuracy Cpk data for all SCHMOLL machines over the past three months is consistently above 1.33, meeting capability requirements and ensuring stable process performance.

3. Process Compliance

The drilling process employs diamine back plates, 0.17 mm aluminum sheets, and new UC drill bits. All materials and tools conform to operating specifications, reducing variability risk.

4. Browning Treatment Effectiveness

Micro-etching rate was measured at 1.5 µm. Thermal shock testing with Tin solder (5 cycles at 288℃ for 10 seconds) showed no delamination, confirming strong bonding between inner copper and dielectric layers.

5. Lamination Curing Results
The lamination parameters of the problem batch were reviewed:
- Temperature rise rate: 2.07℃/min (within 1.2–3.0℃/min specification).
- Curing time: 167 minutes (meeting requirement of ≥90 minutes above 180℃).
- Tg measured at 188.3–189℃, ΔTg = 0.7℃ (within Tg ≥175℃, ΔTg ≤5℃ specification).
Hole wall roughness <15 µm confirmed brittle dielectric behavior. Overall, lamination parameters remain under control.

6. Resin Flow During Pressing

Current pressing program: heating rate 2.1℃/min, material temperature 90℃, pressure 100 psi, curing temperature 185–210℃, curing time 160 min. Given the 4 oz inner copper thickness and removal of nonfunctional pads in layers 7–10, resin flow sufficiency requires further testing to ensure dense filling of copper-free areas.

7. Drilling Parameters

Special program (#7) is applied for thick copper boards, with drill bits resharpened twice and a hit count of 500 holes for diameters >1.0 mm. Cutting force may impact hole walls and induce dielectric cracks. Validation testing is required.

8. Stepped Drilling Mode

The current fourth-type stepped drilling mode (3-step down) involves hovering at segmented points for 100 ms. Heat release is insufficient, and spindle swing may impact sidewalls, leading to nail head formation and copper pad pull-away risk.

9. Sampling Method for First Article

Cross-sections after every 10 holes showed no cracks at full ground design locations. However, random sampling revealed horizontal cracks near maximum hit limits, especially at stepped drilling hover points. This indicates a correlation between stepped drilling mode and crack formation.

10. Environmental Factors

The drilling workshop maintains standard temperature and humidity control. Dust suction negative pressure measured at -14.6 KPa is within the required -(12–20) KPa range. No abnormalities were found in environmental conditions.

Summarizing the above 4M1E inspection results, no abnormality was found in the drilling process in terms of manpower, machine, material and environment, and no abnormality was found in the lamination process and quality. Based on the fact that the cracks in the hole wall are localized and located at the position where the stepped drilling is suspended, it is inferred that the horizontal cracks are related to the stepped drilling mode. It is also found that there are deficiencies in the method of checking the First Article of Drilling, which can’t accurately find out the quality problems of the drilled holes in a timely manner.

fig 10


Hole wall dielectric crack improvement plan

Z-directional crack improvement
For large holes with cracks in dielectric caused by the impact force of drilling, improvements can be made in three ways:
(1) Reduce the resharpened cycles and maximum hit count of drill bits, improve the cutting force of drill bits, thereby reducing the impact on the hole wall.
(2) Optimize inner layer nonfunctional pad design, add nonfunctional pad on some layers to mitigate the impact force when drilling.
(3) Optimize pressing program. Inner layer copper-free area is low pressure zone during lamination, resin flow of prepreg is slow, so the resin flow window of the prepreg can be increased by increasing the heating rate and increasing the pressure in advance, so as to make the copper-free zone to be filled with resin more tightly and improve the impact resistance of dielectric when drilling.

According to the above plan, a Design of Experiments (DOE) approach was developed for validation testing. The initial status of each parameter prior to testing, along with the corresponding parameter levels used in the DOE design, are presented in Table 2.

Table 2Following a 3-factor, 2-level DOE design, 1 run was performed, using 16-layer production board testing with 6 panels per test and 480 large 1.30 mm holes per panel (including 160 holes with separate pads on inner layers). After drilling, starting from the 100th hole, cross-sections were taken every 50 holes for 2 holes (i.e., total number of cross-sections per test run was 96) to observe the status of the hole wall cracks, and the results are summarized below Table 3.

Table 3

Defect Rate Analysis and Optimization of Z-Directional Cracking Parameters

The defect rate data presented in Table 3 was analyzed using Pareto plots (Figure 12) and main effect plots (Figure 13). The analysis identified parameters C (drill bit service life or hit count) and A (inner layer pad design) as significant contributors to defect occurrence, with parameter C (new drill bits) being the most influential. In contrast, parameter B (lamination program) was found to be statistically non-significant

Comparative evaluation of optimized configurations revealed that the defect rate associated with inner layer pad design A1 was lower than that of design A2. Similarly, the defect rate for lamination program B2 was marginally lower than that of the existing production parameter B1. Notably, the defect rate for the optimized drill bit hit count C2 was significantly lower than that of the existing production parameter C1

Further analysis of cross-sectional defect data across varying hit counts (Table 4) showed that the existing drilling parameter resulted in hole wall cracks at a hit limit of 300 holes. In contrast, the optimized drilling parameter combined with inner layer pad design A1 exhibited hole wall cracks only at a hit limit of 450 holes. Based on these findings, the hit limit was adjusted to 400 holes to ensure process reliability.

Accordingly, the recommended parameter combinations for mitigating Z-directional cracking in thick copper boards are defined as follows

(1) Inner layer pad design
Optimized design A1, that is, the inner independent pad retains L2, L4, L5, L7, L10, L12, L13, L15, deletes L8-9. Promote the design rule that the inner independent pad symmetrically retains half of the inner layers, and consecutively deletes copper pad no more than 2 layers.
(2) Pressing program or lamination recipe
Optimized parameters B2, i.e., heating rate 2.5 ℃ / min, material temperature 80 ℃ with pressure of 100 psi, curing 185 ℃ - 210 ℃ to maintain 160 minutes.
(3) Drill bit service life
Optimized parameters C2, i.e. new drill bits for large hole sizes(≥1.0 mm), hit count 400 holes.

Fig 12

 

Table 4


Hole wall horizontal directional cracking improvement
The drilling machine is normally equipped with four kinds of stepped drilling modes, all in three steps (Figure 14), of which the first mode is to exit the drill bit from the surface of the board after the completion of each step, and then proceed to the next step. In this mode, drill bit doesn’t remain in hole wall in-between each step.

The second mode is to exit the drill bit from the surface of the board after the completion of the first step, and then proceed to the second step, after which the drill bit exits to the first step of the depth of the drilling and then proceeds to the third step, which causes repeated impacts to the position of the first step during the second step. The second step of this mode will cause repeated impacts on the first step of the drilling position, which may lead to quality risks.

The third mode is similar to the second, but the retraction distance is longer, also with quality risks.

The fourth mode is the current production mode, after each step of the drilling, the drill bit is hovering for 100 milliseconds and then the second step is carried out, and it is recognized that the copper pad is pulled away from the hole wall in the hovering position.

According to above stepped drilling modes of the drill bit running route, the 2nd, 3rd and 4th modes are set to have the drill bit to stay in the hole in-between each step, there is quality risk for the hole wall. Therefore, the stepped drilling mode is modified, use the 1st mode and one-step direct drilling to verify the drilling quality result, and then, to take cross-sections by 12 holes/test after 500 hit counts, and the results are summarized in Table 5.

Table 5

Analyzing from the test results, no horizontal direction crack on the hole wall was found in both drilling modes, but the cross-sections of the 1st stepped drilling mode found obvious thread shape and drilling smear on the copper surface between L1 and L3 of the hole (Fig. 15), over 40% of the cross-section found such problem. The cross-section observation of these boards after plating still found smear residue, which will lead to the inner layer connection defects, resulting in PCB thermal reliability risk (Fig. 16). Therefore, it is recommended to use one-step direct drilling mode for small holes in thick copper boards instead of using stepped drilling mode.

Fig 14

Fig 15Conclusions
1. Failure Modes of Hole Wall Cracking
Two distinct failure modes were identified in thick copper printed circuit boards:
• Z-directional cracking within the dielectric of the hole wall.
• Horizontal directional cracking (pad pull-away) of the inner non-functional pad.
Z-directional cracking is primarily influenced by the design of inner non-functional pads and the drilling force exerted by the drill bit. Horizontal directional cracking is associated with the stepped drilling mode.

2. Optimization of Z-Directional Cracking Parameters
Design of Experiments (DOE) testing confirmed that drill bit cutting force (especially when using non-resharpened bits) and independent inner layer pad design are significant factors affecting Z-directional dielectric cracks in large holes. The optimized parameters are as follows:
• Drill bit service life: For holes ≥1.0 mm, use new drill bits with a hit count limit of 400 holes.
• Inner layer non-functional pad design: Retain at least 50% of non-functional pads across inner layers; avoid continuous deletion across more than two layers.
• Lamination recipe: Apply a temperature heating rate of 2.5 ℃/min, with the pressure turning point set at 80 ℃ and 100 psi.

3. Improvement of Horizontal Directional Cracking
Based on 4M1E root cause analysis, horizontal cracks in small hole walls were linked to the stepped drilling mode. Comparative testing between drilling modes demonstrated that one-step direct drilling effectively mitigates horizontal cracking without introducing other quality issues.

Go back to Contents

 

Section 6

The AI Boom is Driving Technological Change at Every Level, Reshaping Supply Chains and Business Strategies
Published: 02 January 2026
by Alun Morgan

AI investment shows no signs of slowing, prompting concern about what happens when it eventually does.

Victor Huang has described ChatGPT’s arrival as AI’s “iPhone moment,” when the technology’s potential to change the way we live became clear to all. Indeed, the publication of large language models (LLMs) is arguably the most powerful innovation we have seen so far, enabling widespread user engagement spanning personal and professional purposes. Resulting from this, acceptance has snowballed and more and more of us have come to trust and rely on AI assistants. In turn, mainstream use has driven further improvements, as successive updates have delivered more humanlike interactions and additional capabilities.

Within a short space of time, it seems, an AI-based solution has become available for almost everything. In some of the most contentious examples, AI is giving us original novels, including new works in the style of our favourite authors, and virtual film stars. At the same time, the Albanian government has even put an AI – complete with a traditionally dressed avatar – in charge of its national procurement department. On a more day-to-day level, many of us are discovering how much we need the skills AI can bring to our lives, for finding information on the Internet, organizing our digital content, taking better selfies and fulfilling job responsibilities.

On the one hand, edge AI and tiny machine-learning (ML) applications, while on the other, cloud data centres are where we find the heavy lifting for social media, business applications, and intensive analytics. The AI data centre server market has become a huge opportunity for equipment vendors as operators upgrade their data centres to meet the explosion in end-user demand. Already worth almost $300 billion, currently representing 17% of the total server market by value, it’s predicted to grow another 20% in 2026.

The effects permeate the entire hardware supply chain, extending to materials needed for chip-packaging substrates and PCBs for high-performance accelerator cards and motherboards. This is advanced, high-end materials technology, including low-CTE quartz glass and ultra-low-profile copper foils needed for high-layer-count boards. The boards are made using advanced techniques such as semi-additive process (SAP) and modified SAP (mSAP) for precise control over circuit dimensions, allowing designers to achieve feature sizes as small as 30µm and traces of 15µm width. Some advanced mSAP and full SAP can achieve even finer features, down to 5-10µm. The opportunities for AI data centre equipment present a powerful lure for materials suppliers and fabricators to focus more sharply on high-end products or even realign their businesses away from PCB fabrication and into IC packaging. As AI processors and high-bandwidth memory drive demand for high-performance substrates, this is a $20 billion slice of the action in a global semiconductor market poised to reach $1 trillion in revenues by 2030.

Attracted by the prospect of greater margins, some suppliers are moving higher up the value chain and out of their traditional markets for conventional standard materials. While not all are following this trend, shortages and price increases are likely for these products as the supply chain adjusts and other companies in different geographic areas take over.

As consumer excitement over AI rises to ever-higher levels, however, signs of dissent are appearing. Doubters question whether the current boom is a bubble that’s about to burst. While arguments rage on either side of that debate, we must consider at least one spectacular precedent: the telecom industry of the early 2000s. Some of the industry’s biggest and most successful hardware suppliers, which built for what they thought was limitless demand, suddenly found themselves holding vast unsold inventories and were forced to revise their forecasts. Multi-billion-dollar write-downs followed, and key players suffered enormous pain in the stock markets. While some are even now just regaining their pre-boom market valuation, others went bust in the debacle, along with many overhyped dotcoms. We are certainly experiencing a hardware boom today, as data centres invest in new AI servers. In the historical telecom example, spending stopped suddenly due to the dotcom bust as operators stopped spending on hardware and reverted to their normal investment cycle of about 5-10 years, which is the typical lifetime of carrier-grade switches.

Today’s top computing companies estimate the lifetime of an AI server at 3-6 years. Investment could slow, although the timing is very difficult to predict accurately. After the telecom bust, a major materials supplier asked me to carry out an analysis to learn whether similar issues in the future could be anticipated and avoided. Notionally, of course, it’s easy to predict a fall happening sometime because demand cannot continue rising forever. In reality, dynamic high-tech markets that are constantly creating new services and capabilities have many variables as well as many unknowns. With so many interrelated and abstract factors in play, accurately pinpointing the timing and extent of any downturn is practically impossible.

This time, will we learn the lessons history teaches us? Few can resist the excitement of a boom, and shareholders will always expect executives to follow the money. Right now, data centres are still investing in hardware, and the market is expected to continue growing strongly. Sooner or later, however, every bubble bursts and all will be affected in some way. The industry needs to combine dynamism to make the most of the market highs with the resilience to handle the inevitable lows.

Go back to Contents

 

Section 7

ICT Symposium Review: Sustainability and the Circular Economy
October 9, 2025.  Pete Starkey, I-Connect007

Emma HudsonIt was pleasant autumnal weather as we made our way once again to Meriden, the nominal centre of England, for the 2025 Annual Symposium of the Institute of Circuit Technology. Delegates were welcomed by technical director Emma Hudson who introduced and moderated a skilfully coordinated programme, focused on the highly relevant theme of sustainability.

The opening presentation was delivered by father-and-son duo Jonathan and Max Barrett from Sustainable Engineering, sharing their insights on how the manufacturing industry is evolving to be more circular and sustainable.

Jonathan Barrett founded the Sustainable Engineering Alliance, which brought together a group of organisations that have committed their corporate brands and technologies to building a better world by reducing the environmental impact of the products manufactured by OEMs ranging from aerospace and automotive through to medical and consumer products. Max Barrett had previously been a journalist and filmmaker, and is helping to facilitate the content that his father is producing within the industry, gathering case-study information on sustainability and sharing it through public forums.

Jonathan BarrettThe Barretts are on a journey to identify the most forward-looking sustainable technologies, products, services and materials, and to assemble a comprehensive database to present to tens of thousands of design engineers world-wide.

Jonathan Barrett began with an overview of the regulatory frameworks and standards affecting manufacturing industry, together with their compliance timelines, and continued with descriptions of a series of case studies that have given opportunities to examine the core pillars driving sustainable design and circular economy.

He commented on the prevalence of “greenwashing,” the tendency of certain companies to overstate their achievements and to portray a misleading image of their environmental responsibility without being able to back their claims with data.

Max BarrettThe Barretts took turns discussing an extensive series of key topics, including reduction of embodied carbon, durability, functional efficiency, minimisation, weight reduction, integration, reliability, recovery, repairability, repurposing, and maintainability, with specific examples and meaningful one-liners: "Repair is the first line of defence against waste" and "Maintenance should be intuitive, not a puzzle to solve."

Smart design reduces manufacturing complexity and production costs while improving product quality and reliability. Combining functions reduces part count and complexity, particularly where the combined functionality exceeds the sum of the individual parts. Durability is about maintaining performance and reliability, not just lasting longer.

And whereas the importance of design-for-assembly has long been recognised, design-for-disassembly is becoming an equally significant consideration.

Materials recovery reduces virgin material demand and supports circular supply chains. An example of the creative redeployment of products and components in new contexts is the repurposing of decommissioned wind turbine blades into sustainable infrastructure.

Sustainable packaging protects products effectively while minimising environmental impact and supporting circularity. Smart logistics reduces emissions and improved efficiency, while weight reduction gives the benefits of improved efficiency in transport and aerospace.

On the specific topic of functional efficiency, the discussion focused on electric motors and the delivery of maximum performance with minimal input. It is estimated that 45% of the world’s electricity is converted into motion by motors, with an increasing emphasis on reducing energy consumption by improving their efficiency. Efficiency levels of electric motors are classified on a scale from IE1 “standard efficiency” to IE5. Max Barrett reported that a new generation of magnet-free synchronous reluctance motor technology offered IE6 “hyper-efficiency,” with a 20% reduction in energy losses against comparable IE5 motors.

As an illustration of minimisation, Jonathan Barrett described how a titanium USB-C port for a smartphone can be 3D-printed to be thinner and stronger, while using 33% less material than a conventional forging process.

An amusing, but very effective example of practical energy saving described by Max Barrett was the use of a robotic dog in a Mercedes-Benz factory to “sniff-out” compressed air leaks, enabling them to be promptly repaired, which significantly reduces the plant’s energy consumption.

“How sustainable is my product?” Jonathan Barrett concluded the presentation by running a live online lifecycle assessment with a free-of-charge tool named EcoScan. He chose at random an electric kettle as his subject and simply responded to the prompts of an AI consultant to receive a meaningful screening-level product impact assessment report, together with a bill of materials and a list of key next steps—a convincing example of the sort of facility that is increasingly becoming freely available.

Energy Transitions

Dr Steven FawkesAn energy transition is a broad shift in technologies and behaviours needed to replace one source of energy with another. Dr. Steven Fawkes from ZPN Energy gave a historical perspective on energy transitions, discussed the changes currently being experienced, and offered some grounds for optimism in the future.

His example of a pre-industrial energy system was a water wheel, and the first energy transition was to coal, which had powered the industrial revolution, turned Britain into the first urban nation and was the industry that made almost all others possible. The second energy transition began in 1859 in Titusville, Pennsylvania, when Edwin L. Drake struck "rock oil" and started the oil rush in America. The third energy transition was to natural gas in the 1970s, and the 2000s saw the beginnings of the present transition to renewables.

The last 25 years have seen a dramatic fall in the costs of renewables and storage. Fawkes’ graphs showed a 99.6% decrease in the global price of solar photovoltaic modules since 1980, an 80% decrease in the global cost of wind installation since 1984, and a 99% decrease in the global price of battery cells since 1991. Consequently, renewables are now beating the incumbents by substantial margins.

Solar is currently the largest source of electricity capacity globally, and the boom in Chinese production of solar panels has saturated the global market. They have become so cheap they are actually being used as garden fences in the Netherlands and Germany—perhaps not as efficient as rooftop panels, but offset by significant savings in scaffolding and labour costs.

Fawkes looked into the next 25 years. The fifth energy transition has started and is accelerating as solar and battery prices continue to fall. In the next stage of the transition, the focus will be on electrification, distributed energy, and small-scale close-to-the-point-of-use energy systems.

The old electricity market is centralised, predictable, and vertically integrated, with the energy flowing one way, from generation to end customer. The electricity market is currently in transition to a distributed, flexible, horizontally-networked, multi-directional, cross-vector system. Consumers are becoming “prosumers,” able to both consume and produce, and every building could be a battery and a power station.

So what will that mean for us? Fawkes referred to recent decisions by Ofgem, the energy regulator for Great Britain, that would enable every building and facility to participate in and profit from the market. P415 means that by using solar and batteries, all types of buildings and processes can participate in new markets. P442 means that we could benefit from a license-exempt supply of fully traceable renewable power without non-commodity costs and higher export prices.

So, effectively, together with the falling cost of solar and batteries, there are opportunities to use the technology and the regulatory changes to generate revenue. “And saving money is boring compared to making money!”

In his conclusion, Fawkes quoted the American energy policy analyst Amory Lovins, “Always remember: People don’t want energy, they want warm showers, cold beer, comfort, mobility and illumination.”

Scaling Up

Steve DriverSteve Driver from Jiva Materials remarked that, although institutes like ICT and EIPC are great platforms for new ideas, many new ideas remain as ideas and don’t get off the ground because they don’t have a driver (the pun probably was intended…).

In his inimitable style, good-humoured modesty carrying a serious message, he shared his experiences of scaling-up a sustainable laminate from development to commercialisation.

Moving on from ideation and proof-of-concept requires a change of narrative, using words like “production” and “factory” in place of “laboratory” and “samples,” talking about “capacity” and “lead times,” not “testing” and “verification.”

Driver’s definition of scale-up really means moving from start-up, having more than 10 employees, having raised more than £1m, having stabilised or verified its demand or business model, having the potential to generate revenues of £1m-£3m, and having a plan.

With specific reference to Jiva’s Soluboard product, he discussed his strategy and progress, and how he had addressed and overcome some of the obstacles he had encountered along the way.

His first challenge has been to position his product: He didn’t want it to become “just another item on the shelf.” Although Soluboard has one remarkable attribute—its recyclability—it is not an appropriate laminate for all applications. But the OEM has a choice, and sustainability is a new criterion to consider. So, Driver introduced the concept to selected OEMs on the basis that Soluboard will make the waste more valuable and that it will reduce carbon in manufacture. His objective is to get Jiva’s material specified on the drawing. From the PCB fabricator’s point of view, it is not a drop-in replacement “but PCB fabricators are clever!”

He chose to focus Jiva’s efforts on a handful of OEMs who were interested in cooperating. “We worked our socks off for no revenue but won an opportunity!” and he showed examples of some of the PCBs that have been successfully manufactured.

In scaling-up the operation to meet customer and investor expectations, a big question was where geographically to locate it. The decision was made to begin with a reel-to-sheet line in England. Principal objectives were to grow revenue faster than expenses by leveraging the technology and refining the processes, and to expand market share with the goal of dominating the market rather than just surviving in it.

Huge challenges with raw materials had to be overcome. In order to ensure batch-to-batch consistency, Jiva chose to take control of its resin formulation at source and to blend its own bespoke polymers. Although the original material chosen for reinforcement was flax, this was very expensive, and jute was chosen as a lower-cost alternative. However, it was difficult to produce a consistent fine fabric with jute, and it was replaced with Lyocell, a spun cellulose fibre. The sample of woven Lyocell fabric that Driver handed round was lightweight and appeared homogeneous.

An accepted physical limitation of Soluboard is the 220°C melting point of the polymer. Therefore, low-temperature soldering is mandatory, and a tin-bismuth-silver alloy gives good results. A current challenge is to achieve UL94V0 flammability rating, and it is hoped to qualify by the end of Q4 2025.

In printed circuit manufacture, Soluboard has been demonstrated to be compatible with normal process chemistries. Blackhole and Shadow metallisation technologies enable the production of high-quality plated-through-holes.

Driver’s final slide summarised the current situation: “We have a proven recipe and a proven process, with over 50 pilot production runs to date. Soluboard is currently under review with three major OEMs. Jiva is ready to scale!”

Digital Twins

Robrecht Brelis“Digital twin equals digital win” was an appropriate title for the presentation from Robrecht Belis, director surface finishing at Elsyca in Belgium, who stressed the critical importance of a good copper balancing and discussed the benefits of using a digital twin for optimising plating processes and getting copper thickness control “right first time.”

Market trends and high-density interconnect technologies are pushing PCB designers to pack more components into smaller spaces; layers are becoming denser and thinner, and the need to maintain controlled tolerances for the thickness and width of traces across the entire PCB is increasingly difficult to achieve. Getting it wrong could seriously impact design and production workflow and cause substantial cost and lengthy delays.

He proposed a simulation-based validation workflow, with a copper deposit and balancing check at design, RFQ, CAM and production stages, resulting in reduced time to market, lower development costs, more robust design, and less material waste. At the design stage, simulation software can analyse the layer thickness distribution and automatically generate copper-balancing areas where they are needed. These features don’t form part of the electronic circuit but serve to improve thickness distribution in the plating process. Belis illustrated the effect with a before-and-after “heat map.” The copper balancing operation was automatic, fast, consistent, and user-independent.

It is possible to integrate software into ECAD and CAM tools to determine whether a design is satisfactory for production without additional balancing, whether it would be acceptable if additional balancing were added, or whether it is not fit for production and would have to be modified.

The plating process itself could be modelled as a digital twin. Belis explained the procedure of gathering and characterisation of infrastructure properties, measurement and quantification of data, and combination of the relevant aspects into a digital twin. Outcomes were upfront plateability analysis, definition of mitigation strategy and upfront validation of process strategy. For example, custom screening tools could be created to be incorporated in the plating cell to improve distribution on specific designs.

Belis gave many examples of positive user-feedback, particularly regarding increases in first-pass yields on new parts, energy savings, and cost reductions. It was clear that a key takeaway is the breaking-down of the wall between PCB design and fabrication.

Practical Realities

Hannah WhitmoreReasons why PCB manufacturing must embrace sustainability, and some practical realities of how the biggest challenges were being addressed in a leading UK PCB fabricator, were eloquently detailed in the concluding presentation by Hannah Whitmore, HSE and sustainability manager with Amphenol Invotec.

The key categories she listed were regulatory pressures, cost and risk, resilience, customer and OEM expectations, and reputation and talent attraction in a competitive sector. In the PCB lifecycle, impacts occur in materials, energy-intensive manufacturing processes, chemicals, rinsewater and effluent, and end-of-life considerations. Key regulatory drivers include UN Sustainable Development Goals, RoHS and WEEE obligations, UK REACH, PFAS scrutiny, energy and carbon reporting, HSE ACOPS adherence, and ISO 14001/50001 compliance.

So, where to start? Data! She stressed the importance of establishing core metrics and setting a baseline from which progress could be tracked. Examples were the costs of energy, water, chemicals, and waste per square metre of board produced.

As well as CapEx constraints, some of the greatest challenges to sustainability in PCB manufacture are effluent complexity, hazardous chemistries, PFAS surfactants under regulatory pressure, energy hotspots, yield and scrap losses, and maximising recycling opportunities,

There was scope for simple small changes, short-term actions and quick efficiency wins, but very few in the audience envied the enormous task that Whitmore’s job entailed, although she remarked that thankfully she has positive support and cooperation from all areas of the business. She emphasised the importance of tracking the benefits of a change and not forgetting to register all the work that has gone into it.

Her list of medium-term actions included replacing legacy chemical processes with lower-temperature or higher-activity chemistries, installing electrowinning on copper-rich effluent streams, etchant regeneration, and upgrading to laser direct imaging or inkjet imaging wherever possible. Projects for the long-term include partial closed-loop water, using ultra filtration, ion exchange or reverse osmosis, together with smart controls. She also foresaw the time when environmental product declarations and product carbon footprints for key products will be integrated into bids for contracts.

Whitmore ended her presentation by sharing a roadmap for the future, which involved setting 2030 targets for energy, water, waste, and key hazardous substitutions, using UNSDG targets to align the company’s policy with globally adopted targets, creating a line-by-line opportunity register with CapEx, opex, and payback. A cycle of plan-do-check-act for review and improvement will be established, with internal auditing to check and confirm compliance, and there will be a monthly review and report via the SECR reporting scheme.

Leigh AllinsonICT vice-chairman Leigh Allinson brought proceedings to a close, thanking the presenters for sharing their experiences and all the delegates who have made the effort to attend. He proposed a particular thank you to Emma Hudson for her efforts in organising and managing a splendid event.

I am grateful to Alun Morgan for kindly sharing his photographs.

Pete Starkey
I-Connect007

Go back to Contents

 

Section 8
Leading-Edge Developments in Electronics Manufacturing.
Institute of Circuit Technology Winter Seminar.
Hinckley, Leicestershire, UK. 3rd December 2025.

 

MatBeadelEarly fog made the journey challenging for those travelling from afar, but it lifted to reveal a clear blue December sky over Hinckley, which is actually closer to the exact geographical centre of England than the familiar Meriden venue, for the Institute of Circuit Technology winter seminar. An intriguing programme, focused on some leading-edge developments in electronics manufacturing, more than justified the effort to attend.

ICT chairman Mat Beadel welcomed delegates and introduced the first speaker, Jonathan Jones, process engineer with embedded-die packaging specialists RAM Innovations, who described the development of novel manufacturing technologies and the benefits of advanced embedded packaging for wide-band-gap semiconductors.

JonathanJonesJones explained that RAM had established the capability to package multiple electronic components using PCB methodology, to produce circuits optimised for size, weight and power density, with a unique solution for high-current connect and thermal management.

He demonstrated the benefits of RAM’s three-dimensional “heterogeneous integration” approach, with semiconductors and other components embedded within the printed circuit board. Compared with traditional two-dimensional surface-mounting of components, with limited opportunity for optimised placement resulting in longer routing of conductive paths and compromised symmetry, heterogeneous integration enabled shorter conductive paths, improved matched impedance, lower parasitics and higher efficiency.

In the specific example of wide-band-gap devices, which offered significant benefits at high switching frequencies compared with equivalent silicon-based power converters, embedding gave an opportunity to reduce the size of filter capacitors and inductors, consequently reducing overall system size, weight and cost. Embedding achieved tighter power loops and allowed capacitors to be placed close to the die, whereas in conventional power converters these components were on the surface and connected with multiple wire bonds.

Jones discussed the robustness and reliability of embedded assemblies, with particular reference to the results of thermal cycling on die-base and die-top sinter and silver epoxy connections, where their superior properties compared with conventional assemblies were clearly demonstrated. In high-power applications, embedded aluminium-nitride ceramic tiles ensured that the module was isolated whilst providing an excellent thermal path for efficient cooling.

Material selection for embedded applications was a critical consideration. Structural integrity was paramount; some challenges currently being addressed related to material stability under thermal expansion and operational stress, and also to resin flow and encapsulation. Meticulous design-for-manufacture was fundamentally important.

During the transition between R&D and medium-volume production, panel size was being increased from 12” x 9” to 18” x 12”, with typically 40 modules per panel, and the emphasis was on maintaining the same consistency and yield as had been achieved on smaller panels. It was an advantage that RAM had their own PCB manufacturing facility, with all of their development work being carried out on production-scale machinery. Jones showed examples of equipment and products.
There had been commercial interest from the automotive industry, as an attractive means of cost-effective manufacture of power modules, eliminating the need for wire-bonding. Copper-metallised dies were necessary to enable direct connection to be made successfully, and there were presently a limited number of suppliers.

SteveDriverICT council member Steve Driver introduced the second speaker, Dr James Claypole, CEO and founder of Ail Arian in South Wales, with a presentation entitled “A silver lining for circular electronics”, pioneering a recycling approach that effectively created a circular ecosystem for printed electronics. Dr Claypole explained the derivation of the curious company name “Ail Arian” as a Welsh language term for recycled silver, although Google’s neural machine translation service informed me that it meant “second money”. Whatever, the process he described was certainly the basis of a clever recycling concept for silver conductive inks.

Dr Claypole began by reminding us that, of the 60 million tons of electronic waste generated last year, less than 20% was recycled. Indeed, in the case of printed electronics, less than 1% was recycled. Silver was the active component in many conductive inks; it was an expensive metal and its price continued to increase. So the development of an efficient reclaim and recycling technique was well justified.

He reviewed the principal ingredients of a conductive ink: a resin consisting of solvent, polymers and modifiers, and conductive particles that could be silver, gold, carbon or an organic material. Because silver was typically in the form of metallic micro-flakes, conventional processes for reclaiming it faced a serious challenge in separating the metal from a dispersion of associated materials.

DrJamesClaypoleWhat if silver could be made magnetic? Dr Claypole’s team of materials scientists had developed a method of forming a “shell” of silver on a ferrite core. Very fine particles of this silver-coated ferrite had been demonstrated to be an excellent conductive ingredient in ink for printed electronics. There was a significant cost saving against pure silver and very little effective conductivity had been sacrificed because of the phenomenon of “edge effect conduction”. And the conductive particles were magnetic. Therefore their recovery from end-of-life printed electronics, smart packaging, biosensors, biodegradable electronics etcetera was greatly simplified.

Dr Claypole showed a video comparing existing technology with Ail Arian’s alternative, using printed RFID tags as the example and demonstrating how easily not only the uncontaminated silver but also the uncontaminated substrate material could be recovered. To close the loop, recovered silver had been reused to make new conductive inks and the first prints with 100% recycled conductive materials had been successfully achieved – a positive step towards the creation of circular electronics.

EmmaHudsonICT technical director Emma Hudson introduced the final presentation, delivered by ICT vice chairman Leigh Allinson who discussed next-generation substrate materials. Typical applications included 5G infrastructure, electric vehicles, high-performance computing and aerospace, and the driving factors included lower loss and stable dielectric constant, higher performance and thermal reliability, together with sustainability and cost reduction. From a development point of view, there was a need to “bridge the gap” between products based on standard glass-FR4 and those with increased functionality, smaller form factors and improved performance.

Not all of the technology requirements could be met with glass-reinforced materials, and both the availability and the choice of ultra-thin glass fabrics were becoming limited by demand. So what glass-free alternative materials were available to support next-generation requirements?

LeighAllinsonAllinson described how his company’s background in thermal management technology, designed resin flow and precise horizontal coating technology, combined with radio-frequency and microwave formulation technology, had enabled the development of a range of resin-coated-copper and resin-coated-foil bondply materials.

He went on to explain that resin-coated-copper bondply is an unreinforced adhesive system coated onto ultra-thin copper foil for use in high-performance and high-reliability multilayer PCB stack-ups. Similarly, resin-coated-foil bondply is an unreinforced adhesive system coated onto polyester film, offering design flexibility in high-performance multilayers.

He described the technology of the horizontal coating process, capable of precise thickness control down to 15microns, and explained that, unlike traditional glass-reinforced prepregs, these glass-free materials eliminate micro-Dk variability from glass weave, ensuring signal integrity at high frequencies and in designs with extremely fine features. Typical resin chemistries are bismaleimide-triazine and halogen-free high-Tg epoxy and the resin-coated copper materials are particularly suitable for MSAP processing.

Summarising the benefits to PCB designers and manufacturers, he mentioned lower dielectric thickness, good adhesion with metal, better laser drilling and better Dk skewness. He reviewed a long list of application examples, including “M+N” PCB stack-ups and embedded packages, concluding that these families of materials represent a leap in PCB bondply technology. The absence of glass reinforcement, combined with electrical precision and superior thermal management, result in properties that enable OEMs and manufacturers to build faster, cooler and more reliable electronics without adding manufacturing complexity.

An excellent seminar rounded off with a convivial buffet and pre-Christmas networking opportunity. Many thanks to the Institute of Circuit Technology and particularly to Emma Hudson for her efforts in organising another splendid event.
Pete Starkey
I-Connect007
December 2025

Go back to Contents

Section 9

Members News

cci eurolam logo 

Alain Khan

CCI EUROLAM is deeply saddened to announce the passing of Alain Kahn, founder of CCI EUROLAM.

He profoundly impacted his colleagues and partners through his commitment, convictions, and humanity. Many said of him that he was a visionary. Looking towards the future, he knew how to anticipate and pass on his knowledge over the last years. We extend our sincere condolences to his family and especially to his daughter Dorothée, to whom he had already entrusted the presidency and management for several years.

graphic logo

Kamal Berberi 2

I’m delighted to share that Kamal Berberi has joined Graphic as our new General Manager.

Kamal brings a wealth of experience from both the electronics and printed circuit board industries, and his track record in leading high-reliability technology businesses makes him an excellent fit for this role. As GM, he will take responsibility for the day-to-day operations of the business, a remit I have overseen for almost three decades. This transition will enable me to devote more time to strategic projects driven at Group level.

David Pike

Managing Director

Read more...

icape

Matt Webb

Recognizing our fantastic Quality Manager Matt Webb on World Quality Day!

While based in the UK, Matt’s expertise and dedication influence processes and quality systems across the entire ICAPE Group globally. Thank you, Matt, for your leadership and the impact you make every day. Read more...

jiva logo

Alan Green

Every office has that colleague. You know the one.

The one who pretends not to enjoy the festive chaos.
The one who raises an eyebrow at tinsel and Christmas trees.
The one who chokes when someone mentions Christmas jumpers or Secret Santa
At Jiva Materials Ltd, ours happens to be Alan Green.

While the rest of us get carried away with the festivities, Alan makes sure quality stays high, processes stay tight, and nothing slips through. Read more...

Go back to Contents

Section 10

Industry News

adeon logo

Hofstetter PCB Group purchases Mass-PCB Vacuum-Filling & Planarising system from Adeon Technologies for starting its Via Filing Subcontract Services.
During the Productronica Exhibition in Munich from November 18 through to 21, Adeon is announcing the sale of the newest 2025 model Via Filling equipment with Large Container System and the Planarising system from Mass-PCB to SMF-Hofstetter from Herrenberg, Germany. 

atotech logo

Introducing Cuprapulse XP7-UA – our advanced vertical reverse pulse plating (RPP) process for package substrate core plating with inert anodes. Designed for cutting-edge applications like AI, 5G, and high-performance computing, Cuprapulse XP7-UA delivers:
- Exceptional copper thickness uniformity: Even on panels with challenging hole density variations
- High throwing power & increased current density for superior quality and productivity
- A simplified two-additive system for ease of operation
- Inert anode technology, that eliminates soluble anode maintenance for improved stability and reduced downtime Read more...

atotech logo

Introducing BondFilm® LDD and BondFilm® LDD SR – our next-generation pre- and post-treatment solutions designed to optimize the laser direct drilling (LDD) process in advanced PCB and package substrate manufacturing.

In today’s high-density designs, every via counts. BondFilm LDD creates an ultra-branched brown oxide layer that absorbs laser energy more efficiently, reducing backscatter and lowering the energy required per pulse. The result is better via geometry, improved drilling precision and higher throughput, particularly when used with state-of-the-art laser systems. Read more...

electra logo

ElectraJet EMJ110 inkjet soldermask contains zero SVHCs — meaning nothing to declare under REACH.

A simple, future-proof choice for manufacturers navigating tightening regulatory requirements. Read more...

eurotech logo

It’s been a big year of progress here at The Eurotech Group. Since closing our Poole site and transferring all flex and flex-rigid PCB manufacturing to our main facility in Exmouth, our focus has been on growth, efficiency, and continuous improvement.

Bringing all production under one roof has allowed us to streamline operations, improve lead times, and strengthen collaboration across our teams. Admittedly, there were a few challenges along the way — as with any major transition, but our team has shown incredible resilience and teamwork throughout. Read more... 

Exception pcb

We’re evolving and proud to share the next step in our journey.

Over the coming months, you’ll start to see our refreshed identity appear across Exception PCB. Our new logo brings us visually in line with the Connexion Technologies group, reflecting the close collaboration, innovation, and shared values that unite us.

We’re proud to be part of the Connexion Technologies group and excited for what’s ahead. Read more... 

garner osborne logo

Following valuable comments made through surveys and conversations, we’re proud to announce a change that will deliver both cost savings and enhanced performance for our customers.

From today, thanks to Solder Connection we are transitioning to Tannlin stencils using the DEK VectorGuard™ frame system developed by Tannlin. This move allows us to reduce stencil costs significantly while introducing a more advanced, flexible solution for PCB assembly. Read more...

graphic logo

Graphic Passes ECJU Audit. 

We’re delighted to share that Graphic has successfully passed another Export Control Joint Unit (ECJU) audit.

Our processes were described as “faultless”, reflecting our commitment to the highest standards in exporting compliance for aerospace, defence, and security markets. Read more...

gspk circuits

Our on-site solar farm now generates around 25% of the electricity used to power our PCB facility. This reduces our environmental impact while supporting more sustainable production for our customers across defence, medical and industrial sectors. Read more...

icape

sustainability   The Sustainability Report You Need

Electronics production is at a turning point — are you ready?

Did you know that out of 53.6 million tons of e-waste generated globally, less than 20% is recycled? Discover the insights shaping the future of the electronics industry. This report covers:

The latest EU regulations & compliance. Breakthrough innovations like recyclable PCBs and smart factories. Exclusive survey data from 100+ manufacturers. Read more...

jiva logo

Transforming Electronics Through Material Innovation

Jiva Materials Collaborates with the University of Glasgow to Advance Biodegradable Circuit Boards for High-Speed Electronics. We’re proud to share that Jiva Materials has been featured in a new research paper from the University of Glasgow’s James Watt School of Engineering, highlighting a major step forward in the development of biodegradable printed circuit boards (PCBs) for next-generation electronics. Read more...

merlin logo

Merlin AOI

The Merlin PCB group has invested in CIMS Galaxy 25µ AOI machines, one for Merlin Flex in Hartlepool and the other for Merlin Circuit Technology in Hawarden. Both machines are the latest technology from CIMS and substantially increases the in-line inspection capability at both facilities. Read more...

schmoll logo

Schmoll Maschinen secured the Silver Award at the prestigious Productronica Innovation Award for our groundbreaking PICO+CO2 hybrid laser technology.

This hybrid system sets new industry standards by combining the ultra-clean processing of the picosecond laser source with the efficiency of the CO2 laser. This powerful combination enables unparalleled precision, speed, and material versatility for complex PCB and advanced packaging applications. Read more

ventec logo

ventec

The message is clear cost & prices are rising as demand eats capacity – so is now the time to secure your supply chain for key materials?

A quick look at the PCB industry news channel and it is plain to see that there Is a well documented boom in demand for high-end materials for AI, but the impact of the trickle down effect is often overlooked. Read more...

Go back to Contents

 

Section 11 Corporate Members of the ICT  
Adeon Technologies BV Adeon logo adeon.nl
A-Gas Electronic Materials A-Gas logo agasem.com
Amphenol Invotec Ltd Amphenol Invotec logo amphenol invotec.com
Amphenol Trackwise Designs Ltd Trackwise logo trackwise
.co.uk
Atotech UK Ltd. Atotech Logo atotech.com
CCI Eurolam CCI Eurolam logo cci
eurolam.com
Electra Polymers Ltd Electra Polymers logo electra
polymers.com
Eurotech Group Eurotech logo eurotech-group
Exception PCB Solutions  Exception PCB logo exception
pcb.com
Garner Osborne Garner Osborne logo garner
osborne.co.uk
Graphic plc Graphic logo graphic.plc.uk 
GSPK (TCL Group) GSPK Circuits logo gspk
circuits.ltd.uk 
Holders Technology UK Holders Technology logo holders technology.com
Icape Group Icape Group logo icape-group.com
Jiva Materials Jiva Logo jivamaterials.com
Macdermid Alpha Macdermid Alpha logo macdermid alpha.com
Merlin Circuit Technology Ltd Merlin Group logo merlin
pcbgroup.com
Merlin Flex Ltd Merlin Group logo merlinflex.com
Minnitron Ltd Minitron logo minnitron.co.uk
Newbury Electronics Ltd Newbury Electronics logo newbury electronics.co.uk
Pillarhouse Int Pillarhouse Logo pillarhouse.co.uk
Polar Instruments Polar Instruments logo polar instruments.com
Schmoll Maschinen Schmoll logo schmoll-maschinen.de
Strip Tinning Ltd strip tinning logo striptinning.com
Sun Chemical Corp Sun Chemicals logo sunchemical.com
Teledyne Labtech Teledyne Labtech Logo teledyne labtech.com
Ventec Europe Ventec logo ventec-
europe.com
Zot Engineering Ltd Zot logo zot.co.uk 
    Go back to Contents

 

Section 12

ICT Council Members

Council Members

Mat Beadel (Chair), Emma Hudson (Technical Director, Hon Sec, Membership & Events), Chris Wall (Treasurer), Leigh Allinson (Vice-Chair),Richard Wood-Roe (Journal Editor & Web Site), Neil Chamberlain, Steve Driver, Andy Cobley, Jim Francey, Brian Morgan, Pete Starkey, Francesca Stern. 

 

Section 13

Editor's Notes

The ICT Journal

RickSue

Richard Wood-Roe
Journal Editor

Instructions / Hints for Contributors

We really look forward to any input you have. Technical papers, company news, personal news, industry comments or observations.

1. As it is a digital format the length is not an issue. Short is better than none at all!

2. Article can be a paper or a text version of a seminar or company presentation. Please include data tables, graphs, or powerpoint slides. We can shrink them down to about quarter of a page. 

3. Photo's are welcome.

4. Style we don't want out and out advertising but we do recognise that the author has a specialism in the product or process that will include some trade promotion. Sometimes it will be a unique process or equipment so trade specific must be allowed.

5. We can accept virtually any format. Word, Powerpoint, publisher, PDF or Open Office equivalents. 

6. A photo of author or collaborators.

I really do look forward to receiving articles for publication.

Richard Wood-Roe

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

  Go back to Contents